Comments on: Black Rhino Sport-Hunting Permitted by US FWS https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/ Science, Animals, Planet Earth, & More Mon, 29 Jun 2015 00:15:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.2 By: The Survival Wire https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23375 Mon, 29 Jun 2015 00:15:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23375 We members of the Safari Club International donate the money for establishing, training and equipping anti-poaching entities, for teaching scientific wildlife management practices, for restoring habitat and helping to reestablish healthy herds. When a license like this is granted/auctioned off for $50 or $100,000, it is typically granted for an old male which has already passed his genes along- many times. This harvest additionally helps integrate new genetic diversity into the herd by allowing other males to breed. We pay attention to this. We invest the funds raised in these activities and we have conserved hundreds of of thousands of acres of wildlands and helped to reestablish majestic herds in the US as well as in Africa, Latin America and Asia. We put our money where our mouth is.

]]>
By: Bonny https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23218 Fri, 29 May 2015 07:17:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23218 In reply to ctulpa.

Unsubsribe

]]>
By: ctulpa https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23217 Thu, 28 May 2015 17:12:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23217 In reply to Bonny.

Bonny, please understand the facts before posting opinions about the program. The specific Black Rhinos that are the topic of this discussion have been selected by professional rhino biologists and vets in the management of the Namibia Rhino program. They have determined that there are specific old males that are no longer breeding and have become a detriment to the herd. Their genetics are already in the herd from years of prior breeding, however these old males don’t breed anymore, but stop viable younger males from breeding, by fighting and causing severe injuries. By removing these non-necessary non-breeding old males the management plan has successfully increased the breeding rate of the Black Rhino herds by allowing the viable males to breed. So this animal would have been taken out of this herd anyway. The program provides that these specific animals can be removed and sold to generate the funding to enhance the rhino populations through more trans-locations, more protection and community involvement and community benefit. So please understand it is a much bigger picture than just killing a male Black Rhino and is an integral part of a well managed program by Namibia.
Please also give Namibia the credit it deserves in their Rhino management program as they have increased the population of their Black Rhino numbers for enough generations now to be considered from their current IUCN “vulnerable” status (not endangered as you say) to a lesser status of “near threatened” and eventually to “least concern” status.

]]>
By: John William Salevurakis https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23216 Thu, 28 May 2015 17:04:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23216 These hunts make absolutely perfect sense. Certainly, it might be perceived as ideal to have no hunting, enjoy a government or eco-tourism sector adequately funding habitat and species protection, and watch poaching fall to zero. To assume that such a world exists however (particularly outside of the first world), and base policy upon that assumption, sentences these animals to extinction. As it is, there are not enough people willing to pay a sufficient sum of money to take pictures of these (or other) animals and governments do not have adequate funds to set aside lands and protect them against poaching. This is the developing world we are talking about here! Given that, if hunting generates sufficient revenue to reduce the rate of poaching (as one is unlikely to completely eliminate it) below the rate of reproduction, then we have a job well done! Finally, I am surprised by all the environmentalists complaining about these hunts when, if they really REALLY cared, they were (and are) perfectly capable of bidding on rhino permits put up for sale. They could simply pay the money, refuse to hunt, and pay a premium to relocate the animal(s) from areas of high concentration to areas of low (if the current habitat is strained). Generally, this was all put forward by Coase decades ago. The only way to ensure an optimal allocation of rhino is to open them up for bid and let EVERYONE bid…..hunters, non-consumptive users, and even the Asian buyer who presently buys his horn from poaching syndicates. It is only then when the market price of rhino will reach the “natural” level with the monies going to governments and landowners in stead of poachers and middle-men. I am not a free market ideologue, but I believe that, in the developing world, even an imperfect market works better than poorly funded fortress conservation.

]]>
By: Bonny https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23143 Sat, 11 Apr 2015 08:00:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23143 Congratulations on a very thought-provoking article, Aisha. And Bravo! to the Chinese Buddhists and the Indonesian Muslims for leading the way and enjoining their people from killing these animals. I can understand (that’s not to say I agree with) the economic argument behind putting a few animals up as hunting trophies to raise funds for conservation that will save the species, but with so few of these fabulous creatures around it feels like a rash decision in this instance. I’ve never bred sheep, goats – or black rhinos – so my knowledge on the science of genetic selection is limited, but I’d have thought it was a questionable idea to take the alpha male with the very best genes in the herd completely out of the equation. And, finally, I have to say that I just can’t get my head around the mentality of the person who would want to pay a vast sum of money for the chance to kill one of these wonderful beasts. “Hey Honey, I shot one of the very last black rhinos on the planet today,” is a boast that would be greeted with a very stony silence around my dinner table.

]]>
By: Justiceuk https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23140 Fri, 10 Apr 2015 14:46:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23140 hunting is utterly cancerous, a habit of the insane to feebly attempt compensation on lack of self respect. When the animal in question is on the endangered list, it becomes critically important to protect the animal from these savages who have no regard other than blood lust and bragging. These animals are a vital link in the eco system, hunters are not required, not welcome and not valid in their crass claims to be conservationists. If they were in any way correct in their gross misconceptions, there would not be a critical list of near extinction animals now and we may not have lost so many animals from the kingdom, already! Quo Bono!

]]>
By: somsai https://planetsave.com/articles/black-rhino-sport-hunting-permitted-by-us-fws/#comment-23139 Fri, 10 Apr 2015 11:45:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=43827#comment-23139 Hunting is conservation, and in this case that means 5% population growth per year.

]]>