Comments on: Oklahoma Earthquake & Fracking https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/ Science, Animals, Planet Earth, & More Fri, 08 Aug 2014 01:50:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.2 By: Dana Johnson https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-21664 Fri, 08 Aug 2014 01:50:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-21664 In reply to Dana Johnson.

A four day listing of Oklahoma quakes shows we are the most prolific site in the hemisphere most weeks during the year. small but persistent events never seen until fracking was expanded.

]]>
By: Dana Johnson https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-21269 Thu, 31 Jul 2014 01:22:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-21269 In reply to Dana Johnson.

An image of one of many Oklahoma earthquakes today (and the most recent), seen in green, as it relates to the worldwide total of the past few hours. July 30, 2014. All magnitudes, all earthquakes for a few hours time. We are appearing to integrate Oklahoma to the pattern of stress which is continental in scale and cause, yet it seems to be activated by the recent local fracking and disposal wells. This line occurs fairly regularly in the past few years, during a one day period when active.

http://imageshack.com/a/img540/2074/sOGjxK.jpg

]]>
By: Dana Johnson https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-21229 Fri, 18 Jul 2014 21:43:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-21229 This may drive ambitious oil barons wild- gold deposits from earthquakes- fortunately they cannot collect.

http://www.livescience.com/27953-earthquakes-make-gold.html

]]>
By: Dana Johnson https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-21228 Fri, 18 Jul 2014 21:18:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-21228 The deep transfer of near surface liquids occurs over time, influencing subsequent earthquakes,
http://www.livescience.com/46854-rainwater-found-deep-crust.html

Continuing local earthquake swarms are attributed by profesionals ‘probably’ as fracking and related causes,

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/8-small-earthquakes-shake-oklahoma-as-fracking-critics-grumble/

]]>
By: Dana Johnson https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-18393 Sat, 12 Jul 2014 21:19:38 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-18393 In reply to Dana Johnson.

A link for some basic Oklahoma earthquake figures, one of many sources. 830 earthquakes during the past year, up from the averages of a few dozen or less during the previous years for decades of watching. The activity shows a local pattern. Finding the reason for the pattern is important. Today while typing this I was jolted in Oklahoma City by a single 4.3 wave, originating in Guthrie, OK. The quake shook my computer and caused noise. Five quakes today in Guthrie alone, with many others above 4.0 in Oklahoma this year. This is an historical pattern emerging, in an ordered formation.
Our new state government administration is yet claiming there is no connection to recent increased fracking, and apparently also claiming that water/chemical/gas transport is not also involved, for the same reasoning.

http://earthquaketrack.com/p/united-states/oklahoma/recent

]]>
By: Dana Johnson https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-18390 Sat, 12 Jul 2014 20:54:27 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-18390 When the U.S. was hit by a two week heavy rain series last year across most of the northern states, the subsequent runoff showed an unusual earthquake pattern. Only four quakes over 1.5 were displayed in the entire U.S. for the day- a low occurance rate, but each was within a few tens of miles of rivers where the river path was changed by local geology to a greater than 90 degree course diversion. By removing all mapping but the ‘rivers’ selection I had found a distinct cause of 4.5 and lessor earthquakes where surface force and volume was directly involved with the only quakes recorded. No injection waste sites and no wells studied, as the software did not permit, but a clear cause and efect indicated, with miles of separation of events. Stress, or transport, or, simply a ‘gravity anomoly’ was causing small local quakes.
Try the program ‘ Eq3D ‘, by Wolton.net (free), to follow this and fracking influences.
Where satellite studies show high gravity ‘potential’ transients, there are 95-99 percent of all the 5.0 and greater earthquakes. Staging is by locality, not timing of the fluctuations, for 5.0 and larger quakes. Tectonics shows the zones of the ‘transients’.
Earthquakes below 5.0 do not follow the satellite measured gravity transients as often, and most are shallow.
For lessor quakes finding the causes is much more difficult, as we cannot map the underground aquifer transport and stresses any better than the new gravity variance satellites can find the specific incidence causes. More technology, more detail, will do that eventually.

Heavy near surface water volume change(rain runoff), causes local lessor shallow earthquakes.
It follows that fracking can cause lessor local quakes, similarly, involving liquids.

]]>
By: Zachary Shahan https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-20224 Mon, 19 Aug 2013 21:23:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-20224 In reply to Chloe.

Hello, Chloe. Yes, numerous independent studies have shown that fracking increases the frequency and strength of earthquakes in areas with fault lines. The degree of effect varies. And, of course, linking any one such event to something is basically statistically impossible.

How much fracking to you have going on there?

(Btw, I should note that it is the wastewater injection wells that are linked to the increased earthquake activity.)

]]>
By: Zachary Shahan https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13486 Mon, 19 Aug 2013 21:23:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13486 In reply to Chloe.

Hello, Chloe. Yes, numerous independent studies have shown that fracking increases the frequency and strength of earthquakes in areas with fault lines. The degree of effect varies. And, of course, linking any one such event to something is basically statistically impossible.

How much fracking to you have going on there?

(Btw, I should note that it is the wastewater injection wells that are linked to the increased earthquake activity.)

]]>
By: Chloe https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-20220 Sat, 17 Aug 2013 00:22:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-20220 Zachary, we are having abnormal earthquakes in Wellington, New Zealand and we have fracking in New Plymouth and Dannevirke in the North Island. I have never known anything like this last month in 52 years. Remember Christchurch and the earthquakes there –they never thought Christchurch was an earthquake prone area, so ok there was an undiscovered fault line but what set off the spree of earthquakes? I have to investigate this a bit more as I see you say not all fracking causes earthquakes , only those near fault lines–we have a few fault lines in NZ. There may be other places in NZ where fracking is going on that I am unaware of. Would be interested if you have an opinion.

]]>
By: Chloe https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13485 Sat, 17 Aug 2013 00:22:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13485 Zachary, we are having abnormal earthquakes in Wellington, New Zealand and we have fracking in New Plymouth and Dannevirke in the North Island. I have never known anything like this last month in 52 years. Remember Christchurch and the earthquakes there –they never thought Christchurch was an earthquake prone area, so ok there was an undiscovered fault line but what set off the spree of earthquakes? I have to investigate this a bit more as I see you say not all fracking causes earthquakes , only those near fault lines–we have a few fault lines in NZ. There may be other places in NZ where fracking is going on that I am unaware of. Would be interested if you have an opinion.

]]>
By: Zachary Shahan https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-20092 Tue, 16 Jul 2013 08:27:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-20092 In reply to Jim Henry.

The fracking (well, the injection of the wastewater) triggers more and bigger ones. Studies in a number of places have now found this. But, yes, there needs to be some underlying tectonics that make it possible.

]]>
By: Zachary Shahan https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13484 Tue, 16 Jul 2013 08:27:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13484 In reply to Jim Henry.

The fracking (well, the injection of the wastewater) triggers more and bigger ones. Studies in a number of places have now found this. But, yes, there needs to be some underlying tectonics that make it possible.

]]>
By: Jim Henry https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13483 Tue, 16 Jul 2013 03:15:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13483 Lived here over 50 yrs and we`ve had those same small earthquakes for forever. The 5.6 was interesting but I assume that eventually you`ll get one bigger than the last biggest one recorded. Funny thing is they have always been in the same general area(about a 50 mile radius)so I hardly think fracking has much to do with it as they are fracking all over the state.

]]>
By: Jim Henry https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-20090 Tue, 16 Jul 2013 03:15:00 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-20090 Lived here over 50 yrs and we`ve had those same small earthquakes for forever. The 5.6 was interesting but I assume that eventually you`ll get one bigger than the last biggest one recorded. Funny thing is they have always been in the same general area(about a 50 mile radius)so I hardly think fracking has much to do with it as they are fracking all over the state.

]]>
By: Captain Pickguard https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13471 Wed, 09 Nov 2011 18:18:17 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13471 In reply to Robert Lipkin.

If a quake happens at one point on a fault – relieving stress – it will sometimes trigger a quake hundreds of miles away on the same fault system. If the stress is relieved in one place on the fault, it might cascade to the next pressure point. It happens in Southern California and all around the Pacific rim.

OGS says only a small percentage of the gas-shale wells are fracked (5% iirc). Still this site has published a credible if not substantiated connection that deserves to be followed up. Our record on other environmental is very poor, and the closed doors Cheney energy commission that gave blanket immunities to the gas industry nearly a decade ago seems to point to the idea that there might be something objectionable about fracking. This is certainly worthy of further investigation.

]]>
By: john g https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13470 Wed, 09 Nov 2011 16:23:26 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13470 In reply to AL HOBDAY.

So I guess it is just a big mystery why we see a sudden increase of seismic activity and record quakes in the eastern US this year that just happen to be in the proximity of fracking activity. Plus, do you really think these groups are fully compliant with existing law? Do you think they just might be doing things we really don’t know about? Oh, we are the public and would just get all upset about things we don’t understand. Did it ever occurr to you that waste disposal is one of the most criminally lucrative activities on the planet now?

]]>
By: Keith D https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13468 Wed, 09 Nov 2011 02:35:01 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13468 Have you seen this study by the oil and gas tech giant Schlumberger? It is a study on seismicity triggered by hydrocarbon extraction. Even they know that injections can cause earthquakes.

http://www.slb.com/resources/publications/industry_articles/oilfield_review/2000/or2000sum01_seismicity.aspx

]]>
By: GeoStudent https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13467 Wed, 09 Nov 2011 02:31:27 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13467 In reply to GetItRight.

If it is the re-injection of waste-water associated with fracking that is being linked to a rise in quakes, then fracking is still a culprit, as the waste-water (which is highly toxic and massive in quantity, hence the reason it is being disposed of underground and out-of-mind) is a direct result of fracking. This is an important issue and the natural gas industry is not the only industry seeking to dispose of highly toxic waste products via these older, abandoned wells. I have heard it is a method with burgeoning popularity for disposing of all kinds of unseemly side effects of our industrialized society, and that it is considered the more environmentally friendly form of waste disposal. Pray tell these practices come to light for debate, and may we brainstorm for alternatives.

]]>
By: mmmmm https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13465 Tue, 08 Nov 2011 04:32:50 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13465 In reply to Robert Lipkin.

People have lived comfortable lives for thousands of years without the energy we have today. We have several RENEWABLE energy resources readily available to us right now: wind, water and the sun. We do not need to delve into the earth, destroy the environment or pollute the air and water when we have energy sources that are free and allow us to live the same lifestyle that we are living now.

]]>
By: Foonman50 https://planetsave.com/articles/oklahoma-earthquake-fracking/#comment-13464 Tue, 08 Nov 2011 04:09:57 +0000 http://planetsave.com/?p=26224#comment-13464 In reply to Captain Pickguard.

In this data about shale gas and horizontal wells I only see one well in Lincoln County. Many of these wells are miles away from the fault the 5.6 happened on. What’s up with that.

]]>